...So basically, you judged that someone couldn't be the faith he felt he is because he doesn't speak English well [with no idea on if it's his first language], trolled as fake newbs, found something he didn't know about... then decided he was ful...
First- who are you to judge if someone is a newbie? You said "I got seriously Pissed off about Hinduism" yet you, yourself associate being pissed off at one person with an entire religion. That is a pretty "newbie" thing to do.
Second- "his Engli...
personally I would not be using kid gloves.
If you believe he can send something that is powerful enough not only to physically represent itself but to damage a tree that from your words could not have been broken by a peeping tom; then he has eno...
As I have observed, JRRT heavily depends on the framework of the Norse Mythology.
Also, in the Chaos Magic point of view, it is possible to use names of fictional characters for thought-forms.
It is a wonderful idea and a good categorization. For me it looks more towards Chaos Magic, because you are taking Gods from a Fiction.
But remember that Tolkin takes a lot of inspiration from Norse Mythology. It suits very well for our Chaos Mag...